Sorry I will try and keep up with this thread Rich and I are in Washington DC at the FDA until the 16th with limited connectivity. - as to the Acetoin...
Acetoin in of it self is not considered an concern for inhalation. When Acetoin is manufactured it has a purity grade from 73% TO 100% pure. One of the byproducts of the creation of Acetoin is Diacetyl. So you can purchase and use Acetoin and also have Dactyl present. The purer the grade of Acetoin the less diacetyl present. At 100% pure there is no Diacetyl Present. As a manufacture some of our flavors contain minute amounts of Acetoin (which is not considered a risk) and we test to the lowest limits of detection for diacetyl both the ingredients before production and the final products.
Butterscotch, Cream, milk and french vanilla will contain very small amounts of Acetoin. They are tested in their raw for for DA/AP and after the final product is made for DA/AP to insure that we are performing our due diligence on our products.
Reading this all, I have to also say Kudos to Nicvape/Linc for being very up front and answering the questions here.
Thanks Smoky for all of your footwork. I for one am interested.
This is a very touchy subject for some and I want you to know I appreciate your efforts in spite of all the backlash.
As I have said before, for me after so many years of smoking I am not going to worry myself about this.
I do try to use flavors mostly free of the bad stuff but I am not losing sleep over it.
I do still use some bad stuff but I use it sparingly which is good enough for me.
If more vendors would put forth the effort that a few seem to be doing then that would be awesome.
The day will come when they have no choice and it is nice to see some are ahead of the game... so to speak.
I'll be watching......
TFA and FA are thus far the only companies that provide data for every chemical in their flavors.
FlavourArt Clearstream
http://clearstream.flavourart.it/site/?p=366&lang=en
TPA Spec Sheet and Components (go to list for full molecular make-up)
https://shop.perfumersapprentice.com/specsheetlist.aspx
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
As a consumer, I should not have to buy a bottle to confirm that it's safe.and nicvape does theirs by batch #, you need a bottle first to check it..
or, i can give out a batch # and have some one else pop up what they find..
here is one:
batch # SP1410003
It isn't just about me. It's about the vaping community. If a company is touting how safe their products are, then access to their data should be available. My only beef is with companies who claim something is 100% safe without evidence.RP nicvape does theirs by batches.. as soon as the flavoring is made.
no other company does this.
if you have a beef with them doing this, how bout calling them up and letting them know.
i am sure they will listen..
i happen to like i can check back over what i am playing with..
if you don't, that is understandable and maybe you should stick to what you like.
I think that is very transparent. I see only one other vendor here, trying to make something out of his company, Kevin, beside Linc.
Has anyone asked if his flavors are acetoin free? How about Flavor Art and Tfa, don't forget, Capella's and Flavor West!
Are they here for chatting us up and showing proof that their's are just as clean, if not cleaner? If so, show me and if not, why not?
Can anyone get them all to come to this site and show proof?
I will wait right over here in the corner. Watching, after I place my order for nicvape.
Smoky, if they are as good as you say they are, and seeing you did get them to reply, I am buying in.
It isn't just about me. It's about the vaping community. If a company is touting how safe their products are, then access to their data should be available. My only beef is with companies who claim something is 100% safe without evidence.
In terms of communication, I have tried numerous times via email and phone without any success.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
I would rather see batch reports rather than a yearly test. More precise testing that way. Though I think NicVape should allow access without a purchase. Call it a good faith offering to those thinking of buying.
Point being you shouldn't. Just put a section up on the website showing batch reports (current).
Let potential buyers see them.
Not the point I am making. Tout the testing. Good. Show me evidence without a purchase. It's not difficult to do. It's just a document.
Let me just say. I've never seen a single document from FA showing their test results for diketones. Are they available? I've looked. The clearstream results only have a few flavors and this was not testing for diktones. That said, I still believe it's true and trust the company at their word.TFA and FA are thus far the only companies that provide data for every chemical in their flavorings.
FlavourArt Clearstream
http://clearstream.flavourart.it/site/?p=366&lang=en
TPA Spec Sheet and Components (go to list for full molecular make-up)
https://shop.perfumersapprentice.com/specsheetlist.aspx
More info: http://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/fo...acetyl-propionyl-acetoin-flavorings-data.html
I posted the info on VU as well awhile ago.
Acetoin in of it self is not considered an concern for inhalation.
first, they have to admit they are using acetoin. am I not right? and you your self say you have not gotten an answer..
i am saying.. give Linc a fair shot in replying to this thread. to satisfy us all...
let him reply is what I say, over and over and here again..stop with the tactics of if they are using.. let him explain..
We realize that for E smokers, our food flavors are used in a different way as they are not ingested but inhaled, and the presence of diacetyl can be a cause of concern.
For this reason we have carried out massive removal of diacetyl from our flavor collection since November 2010 and product still containing it are clearly identified.
Disclaimer: We produce and sell FOOD FLAVORS which comply with Italian and EU legislation and EFSA reccomendation. They are safe for FOOD use as they are intended to enter the body by the digestive system, not by lungs.
Digestion involves acid breakdown, enzyme attack, and kidney and liver processing. Vapor by the lungs goes directly in the blood stream. Even though due to absence of combustion, vaping can be compared to odor smelling in open air, consumption of food flavors by vaping has not been specifically tested for safety. Flavourart srl can not be held responsible for any claim or damage arising by the use of food flavor by the means of electronic devices as E-vapers, E cigarettes and similar.
Let me just say. I've never seen a single document from FA showing their test results for diketones. Are they available? I've looked. The clearstream results only have a few flavors and this was not testing for diktones. That said, I still believe it's true and trust the company at their word.
The FDA continues to seek additional information to help further clarify any health effects from diacetyl. Is the industry doing anything about the potential health effects to workers? Yes. Because of the potential health risks from repeated exposure, the industry has implemented changes to reduce workplace exposure to diacetyl, including implementing engineering controls such as closed mixing tanks, separate mixing rooms for butter flavors, requiring respirators for mixing room operators, and improving air circulation in facilities.
Just wow........
Is VU going to turn into another ECF where people are afraid to post because of being attacked by others?
I certainly hope not.
I think this thread should get back to what it was meant to be.
Smoky has been to this place and seen things for herself and wanted to share.
Thank you Smoky for that but I wouldn't blame you if you never posted again. (I hope you do though)
If you have questions for Nic Vape then by all means contact THEM.
It is not necessary to beat the OP up like this.
Want batch numbers to check things out....
@wllmc just bought the whole line so he can give you batch numbers for any flavors other than tobacco.
Smoky doesn't have all the answers but is looking for alternatives.
No, I am not Smoky either and I think that was a cheap shot HIC.
I agree I think the issues with the Vendor should be taken up with them, lets all get along and make this UN-like ECF folksJust wow........
Is VU going to turn into another ECF where people are afraid to post because of being attacked by others?
I certainly hope not.
I think this thread should get back to what it was meant to be.
Smoky has been to this place and seen things for herself and wanted to share.
Thank you Smoky for that but I wouldn't blame you if you never posted again. (I hope you do though)
If you have questions for Nic Vape then by all means contact THEM.
It is not necessary to beat the OP up like this.
Want batch numbers to check things out....
@wllmc just bought the whole line so he can give you batch numbers for any flavors other than tobacco.
Smoky doesn't have all the answers but is looking for alternatives.
No, I am not Smoky either and I think that was a cheap shot HIC.
If you have questions for Nic Vape then by all means contact THEM.
It is not necessary to beat the OP up like this.
Smoky doesn't have all the answers but is looking for alternatives.
No, I am not Smoky either and I think that was a cheap shot HIC.
The original post emphasized "vaping safe" and quoted the manufacturer's claims.
I questioned an omission in those claims, and the manufacturer posted an affirmative.
While I fail to see that as a "cheap shot", this exchange has been productive: ingredients are confirmed, for those who want/need to know.
When one comes bulling in with an agenda, it seems easy for them to "forget" or "fail to see" the real and true cheap shots they are/were slinging.The original post emphasized "vaping safe" and quoted the manufacturer's claims.
I questioned an omission in those claims, and the manufacturer posted an affirmative.
While I fail to see that as a "cheap shot", this exchange has been productive: ingredients are confirmed, for those who want/need to know.
Damn, this is like ECF, attacking a member who has helped alot of people and now because she is not being a fangirl of another vender/brand is being attacked. Sheesh.
I really don't know anyone here but smoky has been a great help to me and HIC, you are bullying her even if you think your not...
This is as bad as the ProVari fanboys and girls attacking anyone who does not agree with them.
Lets get back to the original reason for this thread. you elitist can go play with yourself's and leave others alone. It just makes you look like what you really are.
face it, we all smoked cigs and and nothing in vaping at this time can be proven to be worse.
You want safe, then stay home, do not eat, drink or smoke anything.
simple recipe for this one..
2% butterscotch nv
.5% french vanilla nv
if you use more than 1% on the french vanilla, it will cover any other flavoring you try to use..
the good side is.. the highest i have used it was 2% and well.. dont know if it is my throat.. since it is raw..
but i get a custard on it
Looking forward to trying this one..
thanks smoky..
still testing single flavors. sheesh
I'm really enjoying:
2% Ripe Strawberry
2% Real Watermelon
0.25% Lime
Tasty snowcone type flavor!!