Help with FA-Only Lemon Sugar Cookie

[lirruping]

I would like to make a rich, moist, very lemony, lemon sugar cookie using only FA flavorings. I love pies and creams and custards, but I would like this one to be definitely a COOKIE.

So far, I'm thinking:

4-6% lemon sicily and 0.5% lime (cold-pressed)
+ ?some amount of cookie (2% ?)
+ ? some amount of meringue (1% ?)

Other possible additions that occur to me are: vienna cream, vanilla classic, apple pie, fresh cream and custard--but I'm not sure how to proceed without turning it into a pie.

Please advise!

 

[soulshine]

Maybe something like this..minus the Ginger? Might be a good place to start.

http://vapingunderground.com/threads/hics-ginger-lemon-creme-cookies.25514/#post-147787

 

[lirruping]

Maybe something like this..minus the Ginger? Might be a good place to start.

http://vapingunderground.com/threads/hics-ginger-lemon-creme-cookies.25514/#post-147787

This is useful, thank you, soulshine.
I haven't mixed this--in fact I don't think I've mixed ANY recipe that has cookie in the title...DOH! other than Hic's Maple Cream Cookies! I just remembered that recipe. That's where I need to look. Sometimes it just takes a little hand-holding to get my brain working.

The Carr's actual cookies are more wafer/biscuit-like than they are like sugar cookies, and knowing HIC's recipes, the chances are good that it is true to that quality.

Still, I might extrapolate that the basic cookie part of it is as follows:

1% FA Cookie
0.5% FA Custard
0.5% FA Vienna Cream

and continue from there.

If I make progress on lemon bar/lemon sugar cookie, I will be sure to slap it up here. I'm vaping one with lots of baddies in it currently and it's so delicious.. but I need a d-a-a free alternative to hit that spot.

 

[AmandaD]

Here's an old one I used to make all the time, minus the sweetener:
https://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/threads/lemon-cookie-delight.555290/

 

[soulshine]

Looks good Amanda! I may whip this one up tonight!

 

[boxboy]

Here's an old one I used to make all the time, minus the sweetener:
https://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/threads/lemon-cookie-delight.555290/

Made 5ml test of this. Was good enough to make another 30mls. Thanks

 

[AmandaD]

Made 5ml test of this. Was good enough to make another 30mls. Thanks

It's a good simple recipe. I used to make 30mls at a time too!

 

[Huckleberried]

I have that one saved, too. I was looking for the one I saved from we2, but can't find it! Agh!! It was also really good.

 

[Huckleberried]

Oh! I bet I wrote it down. I'll go searching for it.

 

[Huckleberried]

I found it, but it's only 2 FA flavors, with one TFA flavor, but I remember liking it. But @lirruping wants all FA, so... plus, it's not mine.

 

[lirruping]

Here's an old one I used to make all the time, minus the sweetener:
https://www.e-cigarette-forum.com/forum/threads/lemon-cookie-delight.555290/

Thank you, A - this looks very nice.
I think I tried a fruit blend by Bryong70 a long time ago that was very good. I'll have to dig in my notes and see.

 

[Heabob]

Yes the Lemon Cookie Delight is a real nice one.

Edit: BTW I didn't use any sweetener either...

 

[chriss]

I think you should add some berries .. you can mix five star juice american pie with E-liq cube plum berry, I bought these two from CSvape it was really amazing ...

 

[soulshine]

I think you should add some berries .. you can mix five star juice american pie with E-liq cube plum berry, I bought these two from CSvape it was really amazing ...

Wouldn't really be a "Lemon Sugar Cookie" then...would it? LOL We aren't talking about mixing 2 premade liquids that we bought on the internet. But if that idea sounds interesting to you...let us know how it works out for you

 

[lirruping]

I think you should add some berries .. you can mix five star juice american pie with E-liq cube plum berry, I bought these two from CSvape it was really amazing ...

Hey, lemon-raspberry cookie might be tasty... hmm. Before I started doing DIY I was always mixing vendor juices together. When I first started vaping I had almost no personal space where I was living, so DIY was out of the question. Mixing premade, you're limited in what you can do, but it's definitely fun and one up-side is getting pretty much instant results--no steep time needed!

 

[joeyboy]

Cam you get the sugar taste with just FA? I think you will need some cinnamon Ceylon and maybe vanilla Tahiti or classic. Must have some cookie in there. I would add a touch brown sugar.

 

[Bryon]

Instead of using a sweetener in my Lemon Cookie Delight. Try it with the new FA Joy at 1%. I have tried many variations of it. It still my favorite vape. If you have Oba Oba, try that too, makes it a little different.