Pumpkin Spice Coffee - like you get at Starbucks and 7 - 11 this time of the year. I have mixed it straight (coffee, pumpkin spice, EM, sweet cream), with my own Cream Base and with my Cake Base, with the addition of cinnamon and nutmeg (Holiday Spice), with different pumpkin spice concentrates by different manufacturers, with Apple Pie concentrate both as an additive and as a base and with profiles from very low to very high (48%). Next I am going to try Tiramisu concentrate and my Bread Pudding recipe plus pumpkin spice. Unless you have some ideas I can try. Thanks
Pumpkin spice keeps coming up - fall must be approaching. I haven't done anything pumpkin-ish that truly pleases me. I'll have to wander through a corn maze and carve some jack-o-lanterns to get back in the pumpkin mood, given the horrific results I've had in the past. But I'll tell you what I've figured out so far.
Pumpkin Spice flavors usually don't include any pumpkin flavor - just the spices. Make your own; it will be better. FlavourArt's Cinnamon Ceylon is second to none. I use their Clove, too - never tried any others, so can't say how it compares. The best nutmeg-ish flavor I've tried is TFA's Holiday Spice, which also includes a little bit of other compatible spice flavors. Can't make a proper pumpkin pie without ginger; you just need a tiny bit. Nature's Flavors and Flavor West both make ginger; I think NF's is superb, but FW's will do fine as such a minor ingredient. Look at the recipe for your favorite real pie for the ratios of spices that will appeal best to you.
TFA's Pumpkin tastes like a can of plain, unsweetened, uncooked, unspiced pumpkin. It takes surprisingly little to make pumpkin pie. It's a very raw, fresh flavor that needs many additions. Of course, some so-called 'pumpkin spice' actual food/beverage includes no pumpkin at all, so you might not use any. I think it needs it. Brown sugar and/or molasses ought to be included. (TFA Molasses and Pumpkin have diacetyl subs, but there are no alternatives if you want those flavors.)
Actual pumpkin pie is based on creamy, rich, sweet custard. FA Custard is an ideal beginning. It has some high notes to balance the low notes of TFA Pumpkin, and a little caramel-top flavor that would go great on a pie.
With a proper pumpkin pie filling flavor, I'll consider crust last. That's the easy part. It'd be easy to add a perfected pumpkin pie flavor to a good latte (based on FA Espresso) for a knockout dessert coffee, but I have a lot of work to do before that.
I can't imagine a pumpkin-spiced Tiramisu... Bread pudding sounds awesome - what do you put in that?