Oh yeah, I can see this being a whole different animal, lol. Interesting mix ya got there!
FA Cookie is a whole different kinda cookie, IMO. I think the CAP Sugar Cookie is nice, but there's something special about the FA that I just can't do without, so far. To me, the TFA Ch. graham crust is a lighter flavor than the 2 CAP flavors you used, so if you have the NY Cheesecake and want the Cheesecake taste, you could swap, or add, that one, maybe?
I hope the steep works out for you. You might not need to do anything at all.