I have a real love/hate relationship with this dude's band, Periphery. I was a big fan of the founding member, Misha Mansoor, back when Djent wasn't really a thing and he was posting a bunch of rough mixes of really tight, groovy, and spacey, meshugga-esque metal under the banner of "Bulb" over on soundclick and Sevenstring.org. It was fun and intriguing. It just sounded so fresh to my ears at the time. I was like "You can do that?!" I still feel that way about his material, more than a half-decade later.
He wrote Periphery I, got his dream team together, started touring and became an international sensation. Everyone in metal was talking about Periphery and friends. It really was an awesome album, too. I listened to it obsessively, as did many others. It was around this time that I would say "Djent" was in bloom as a genre. It was a time when lots of other dudes were coming out of the woodwork with somewhat similar ideas, each with their own distinctive approaches and compositional quirks/tics. They had their own goals for their music and it could be heard in the quality of their efforts. They were ambitious and well-honed compositions. These people used the style as a vessel to create something truly unique... ...something completely different from what metal fans were used to at the time.
And the whole scene ate it alive. By the time Periphery II came out, they were old hat, but a new audience was busy making it the only significant thing to happen in metal at the time. Metal became over-saturated with shitty Djent bands that people thought were good because they sounded like that one awesome thing that one guy did. Every metal kid out there wanted to be like them. There are probably 1000's of bands all doing the same thing nowadays, just to be that... ...artists with no real sense of identity trying to make names for themselves by doing what's cool. They're the same people who used to be into canned and pressed chugga-chugga y-core bands before they learned to play their instruments well.
They took elements of what was a new iteration of progressive music and rendered it in the form of everything that progressive music is not. They have no vision or sense of musical exploration... ...no original output and no push for innovation. They simply go through the motions. They're stuck on a trend that should have died a few years ago, while most everyone else has moved on. 90% of Djent bands today sound like every Djent song ever.
It's basically metalcore all over again. It suffered from a failure to evolve. Only a few really good bands came out of that movement in one piece. And don't get me wrong, I love me some good old-fashioned metalcore. I just hate most of it.
The original forerunners in the genre went on to do their own things and are still putting out kickass music that pushes the boundaries of everything they've done before. They've managed to overcome the stagnation of the aftermath and carve out their own musical niches. Others quit while they were ahead, which is unfortunate, but they at least left some good music behind for us. Meanwhile, new bands have cropped up and taken up a more honest and true-to-form approach by picking up where those guys left off and pushing onward with their own ideas. It's still a really great era for progressive rock and metal. The future is now.
Periphery has grown a lot as well (I actually think they're better than ever before now,) but because they are basically the archetype of this huge stylistic trend that they themselves played a major role in galvanizing to the point of stagnation that it's reached now, I find it hard to enjoy their newest material. It's stuff that I feel like I should enjoy, but can't because I've heard it done half-assedly too many times. The state of the whole scene has left a bad taste in my mouth.
Sorry to make a blog post in the music thread. It's just that hearing this particular song makes me bitterly nostalgic for a time when this sort of material was totally new to me and deeply impacted my thinking on approaching composition as a musician. It inspired me to try different things and opened me up to the idea of approaching one genre from the mindset of others. To hear all of these musicians take it and bastardize it really gets me down. It's like they completely missed the point that the guys they imitate were trying to convey.