@HeadInClouds for a Vanilla Pizzelle (just picked up some at the market) would I just omit the Anise? Or do I have to add something else? Thanks!
The thought of Pizzelle with no Anise at all makes me sad. lol. If you have it, I really recommend getting in just a little, even if it's 0.25%. If you don't have Anise, then even 0.25% of Marzipan. Either (or both) serve as a contrast - and sweetener - to make vanilla taste even better. In any case, sure, you can go 2%, maybe 2.5%, on Vanilla Classic to make it the most prominent flavor.